Haunted by Atrocity: Civil War Prisons in American Memory (Making the Modern South)

By Benjamin G. Cloyd

During the Civil conflict, nearly 56,000 Union and accomplice infantrymen died in enemy army criminal camps. Even in the middle of the war's surprising violence, the depth of the prisoners' discomfort and the brutal demeanour in their deaths provoked outrage, and either the Lincoln and Davis administrations manipulated the legal controversy to serve the exigencies of conflict. As each side disbursed propaganda designed to persuade voters of every part of the relative advantage in their personal felony method -- not like the harsh inhumanity of the opponent -- they etched hardened and divisive thoughts of the legal controversy into the yankee psyche, stories that may turn out tricky to uproot. In Haunted via Atrocity, Benjamin G. Cloyd deftly analyzes how american citizens have remembered the army prisons of the Civil warfare from the battle itself to the current, creating a powerful case for the ongoing significance of the nice clash in modern America.

Throughout Reconstruction and good into the 20 th century, Cloyd exhibits, competing sectional thoughts of the prisons lengthy the method of nationwide reconciliation. occasions similar to the trial and execution of CSA Captain Henry Wirz -- commander of the infamous Andersonville felony -- in addition to political campaigns, the booklet of felony memoirs, or even the development of monuments to the felony lifeless all revived the painful accusations of planned cruelty. As northerners, white southerners, and African american citizens contested the which means of the struggle, those divisive thoughts tore on the scars of the clash and ensured that the topic of Civil conflict prisons remained controversial.

By the Nineteen Twenties, the loss of life of the Civil conflict new release got rid of a lot of the emotional connection to the battle, and the devastation of the 1st global wars supplied new contexts within which to re-examine the that means of atrocity. for this reason, Cloyd explains, a extra target opinion of Civil conflict prisons emerged -- one who condemned either the Union and the Confederacy for his or her callous dealing with of captives whereas it deemed the mistreatment of prisoners an inevitable end result of contemporary battle. yet, Cloyd argues, those seductive arguments additionally deflected a better exam of the best accountability for the tragedy of Civil struggle prisons and allowed american citizens to think in a comforting yet ahistorical reminiscence of the talk. either the recasting of the city of Andersonville as a Civil battle village within the Seventies and the 1998 establishing of the nationwide Prisoner of battle Museum at Andersonville nationwide historical website demonstrate the continuing American choice for fantasy over background -- a choice, Cloyd asserts, that inhibits a candid review of the evils dedicated through the Civil War.

The first research of Civil conflict reminiscence to concentration solely at the army legal camps, Haunted via Atrocity bargains a cautionary story of the way american citizens, for generations, have unconsciously built their reminiscences of painful occasions in ways in which defend loved beliefs of fantasy, which means, identification, and, finally, a deeply rooted religion in American exceptionalism.

Show description

Quick preview of Haunted by Atrocity: Civil War Prisons in American Memory (Making the Modern South) PDF

Similar American Civil War books

Lincoln's Men: The President and His Private Secretaries

“An intimate portrait of Lincoln, so well-drawn that he turns out to come back alive at the web page. ”—Charleston put up & Courier Lincoln’s males through Daniel Mark Epstein deals a desirable close-up view of the Abraham Lincoln White condominium during the eyes of Lincoln’s 3 own secretaries: John Nicolay, William Stoddard, and John Hay.


“The maximum of our Civil battle novels” (New York instances) reissued for a brand new iteration because the usa prepares to commemorate the Civil War’s a hundred and fiftieth anniversary, Plume reissues the Pulitzer Prize–winning novel greatly considered as the main strong ever written approximately our nation’s bloodiest clash.

Abraham Lincoln and Civil War America: A Biography

In Abraham Lincoln and Civil struggle the United States, historian William Gienapp presents a remarkably concise, updated, and colourful biography of the main respected determine in usa heritage. whereas the center of the publication makes a speciality of the Civil struggle, Gienapp starts with a finely etched portrait of Lincoln's formative years, from pioneer farm boy to flesh presser and attorney in Springfield, to his beautiful election as 16th president of the USA.

Second Manassas 1862: Robert E. Lee's Greatest Victory (Praeger Illustrated Military History)

There by no means was once this type of crusade, now not even via Napoleon wrote accomplice normal Pender of the second one Manassas crusade within which the gray-bearded Virginian, Robert E Lee, got here as shut as he ever may to exterminating his Northern enemies. moment Manassas demonstrated Lee because the South's pre-eminent army commander and the military of Northern Virginia as its strongest weapon.

Additional resources for Haunted by Atrocity: Civil War Prisons in American Memory (Making the Modern South)

Show sample text content

Of this negative war,” the preamble to the prisoners’ presentation said, “has been to deaden our sympathies. . . . Does the misfortune of being taken prisoner make us much less the item of curiosity and cost to our govt? ”79 the reply to the Andersonville captives’ query trusted point of view. even supposing Union prisoners felt deserted by way of their govt, which always established indifference towards the issues skilled via prisoners of battle, they possessed significant “value” to the Union conflict reason. regrettably for Union prisoners, the Lincoln management calculated their “value” otherwise. the truth of the prisoners’ worthy used to be proven via the activities of common Sherman, who, as he marched via Georgia, made no severe attempt to loose the Andersonville prisoners. eighty Sherman’s activities proven the absence of humanitarian morality, other than while handy, within the Union struggle attempt. The propaganda “value” of northern captives as martyrs, observed via a barrage of inflammatory rhetoric and photographs, outweighed the “value” in their lives. Even in the course of the ultimate months of the conflict, as trade resumed and the legal camps slowly emptied, the excoriation of the Confederacy and its prisons endured. With victory handy, northerners endured to equate superiority at the battlefield with ethical superiority. On January 29, 1865, Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts, no stranger to attacking the moral failings of southern society, gave a speech criticizing the congressionally proposed coverage of retaliating opposed to insurgent prisoners in line with the brutal remedy accorded to Union prisoners. “We should still do not anything wherein our state shall forfeit that groovy position which belongs to it within the leading edge of nations,” Sumner pleaded, while he admitted that “when we learn the tales in their atrocities . . . whilst the full scene in all its horror is sooner than us . . . our souls are packed with unutterable pain. ”81 even if Sumner rejected the assumption of retaliation in northern prisons, his speech, reprinted and circulated, however proven the guilt of the Confederacy and the innocence of the Union within the debate over accountability for the felony atrocities. Atrocity and the Origins of Divisive Memoryâ•… 27 regardless of Sumner’s magnanimous stance, refusing to exchange a watch for an eye fixed based on the South’s provocation, the Union government’s activities towards captive Confederates confirmed that, claims of innocence apart, a coverage of de facto retaliation already existed. encouraged through the knowledge released in the home of Representatives file in regards to the brutal therapy of northern prisoners, through the spring of 1864 Union secretary of battle Edwin Stanton licensed a chain of rate reductions within the rations given to accomplice prisoners held within the North as a way to fit these issued to Union prisoners within the South. eighty two The ruthless nature of Stanton’s reprisal deals extra facts of the harmful scale of the Civil conflict. Stanton’s coverage, even though possibly a reaction to the racial atrocities of fortress Pillow, used to be definitely inspired through bitterness and a man-made experience of ethical superiority.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.27 of 5 – based on 7 votes